Cod Liver Oil vs. Fish Oil: Comparison and Health Benefits

A 2023 study in Marine Drugs indicates that fish oil typically contains 30-35% omega-3 fatty acids, making it a more concentrated source of EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) and DHA (docosahexaenoic acid). The extraction process involves processing whole fish or fish parts, not just the liver. 

Fun Fact:  

Did you know that it takes about 3 pounds of fish to produce just one pound of fish oil? That's why quality matters when choosing your supplement! 

Having said that, it's about time to break down what you're actually getting in each bottle, because nobody likes surprises when it comes to their health. 

Nutritional Comparison: Cod Oil vs Fish Oil 

Omega-3 Content 

When comparing cod liver oil vs omega 3 supplements, the concentration differs significantly. Fish oil generally provides higher concentrations of EPA and DHA per serving. A typical 1000mg fish oil capsule contains about 300-400mg of omega-3s, while the same amount of cod liver oil provides roughly 200-250mg. 

Vitamin Content 

Here's where cod liver oil shines. According to research in Nutrients journal (2022), cod liver oil naturally contains: 

Regular fish oil contains minimal amounts of these vitamins unless they're artificially added during processing. 

Purity and Processing 

Both supplements undergo purification processes to remove contaminants like mercury and PCBs. However, a 2024 study in Food Chemistry found that molecular distillation methods used for fish oil can achieve higher purity levels compared to traditional methods for processing cod liver oil. 

Let's get to the good stuff. What can these supplements actually do for you?" 

Health Benefits: Fish Oil and Cod Liver Oil Benefits 

Heart Health Support 

Both supplements may support cardiovascular health through different mechanisms. Research published in Circulation (2023) suggests that omega-3 fatty acids in both fish oil and cod liver oil may help maintain healthy cholesterol levels and support normal blood pressure.  

Other benefits: Omega –3's lowers triglycerides, slows down plaque buildup, and occurrence of arrhythmias. It has anti-Inflammatory effects and reduces the risk of formation of blood clots. It also improves the health of lining of blood vessels (endothelium). 

Fact:  

The American Heart Association recognizes omega-3 fatty acids as beneficial for heart health, though they emphasize that supplements should complement, not replace, a healthy diet. 

Also Read: 10 Highly Inflammatory Foods to Avoid & 10 Anti-Inflammatory Foods to Include in Your Diet 

Joint Comfort and Mobility 

Studies indicate that omega-3 fatty acids may support joint comfort. A 2022 clinical trial in Rheumatology International found that participants taking omega-3 supplements reported improved joint flexibility and reduced morning stiffness. They also reduce inflammation and pain in joints. 

Also Read: Support Your Wellness Naturally: Exploring Tocotrienols' Potential for Inflammation! 

Brain Function Support 

DHA, found in both supplements, plays a crucial role in brain health. Research in Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience (2023) suggests that adequate omega-3 intake may support cognitive function and memory as we age.  

It maintains cell structure and supports communication between neurons and reduces inflammation in the brain. Helps keep the protective lining around brain cells intact, Increases blood flow to brain, learning, memory, cognitive well-being. 

Bone Health  

Though omega 3’s in cod liver oil may also show modest benefits by improving bone quality, decreasing inflammation, and preventing bone decay. These effects are more pronounced in individuals under 60 years of age, females, and non-smokers. 

Specific Benefits of Cod Liver Oil 

Immune System Support 

The Vitamin A in cod liver oil may provide additional immune system benefits.  

Also Read: The 8 Best Foods to Boost Your Immune Health 

Bone Health 

The vitamin D in cod liver oil helps your body use calcium for strong bones and teeth. This is especially important for people at risk of vitamin D deficiency.  

Also Read: Tocotrienols & Bone Strength! What is the Hidden Link? 

Vision Support 

 Vitamin A is a key component of the retina, the light-sensitive tissue at the back of the eye. It helps maintain the health of photoreceptor cells, which are essential for vision. It is particularly essential for vision in low light (night vision). Overall vitamin A is important for healthy eyes and vision. 

Also Read: Tired Eyes? Discover the Antioxidant You’re Missing 

Specific Benefits of Fish Oil 

Higher Omega-3 Concentration 

Fish oil from fatty fish often has more EPA and DHA per dose than cod liver oil. 

No Extra Vitamins 

Fish oil does not have vitamins A or D, so you don’t have to worry about getting too much of these vitamins. 

Myth Buster: "Fish oil and cod liver oil are exactly the same thing." 

Truth: While both contain omega-3 fatty acids, cod liver oil comes specifically from cod liver and contains additional vitamins A and D. Fish oil comes from whole fish tissues and focuses primarily on omega-3 content. 

Before you go crazy and start chugging fish oil like it's your morning coffee, let's talk safety first! 

Safety Considerations and Dosage 

Recommended Dosages 

Health Canada suggests adults consume 250-500mg of combined EPA and DHA daily. For cod liver oil, this translates to about 1-2 teaspoons daily, while fish oil typically requires 1-2 capsules. Remember its best to consult your healthcare provider to find out the right dose that works for your unique healthcare needs. 

The AHA recommends 1 g of EPA/DHA per day. 

Potential Side Effects 

Both supplements are generally well-tolerated, but some individuals may experience: 

Fish oils might prolong clotting times when taken with warfarin a blood thinner medicine.  - Seafood and omega-3s, the Dietary Guidelines for Americans 

            Cod liver oil users should monitor their total vitamin A intake. The National Institutes of Health recommends not exceeding 3,000 mcg of vitamin A daily from all sources to avoid toxicity. 

Should You Take Cod Liver Oil or Fish Oil? 

Choose Cod Liver Oil If: 

Choose Fish Oil If: 

Choosing a High-Quality Omega-3 Supplement: What to Look For 

When shopping for either supplement, research published in Food Control (2024) suggests looking for: 

Key Takeaways  

Make Your Choice Today 

Whether you choose cod liver oil or fish oil, you're taking a positive step toward supporting your health. Cod liver oil gives you omega-3s plus vitamins A and D, while fish oil gives you more omega-3s without extra vitamins. Consider your individual nutritional needs, current vitamin intake, and health goals when making your decision. 

Remember, supplements work best as part of a balanced diet and healthy lifestyle. Consider consulting with a healthcare provider to determine which option aligns best with your specific health needs and current medications. 

Disclaimer: The statements on this website have not been evaluated by the FDA. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. 

FAQ’s  

Q1. How long before I notice benefits?  

A: Omega-3s are more of a long-term investment. Most people notice changes after 6 to 8 weeks of consistent use. 

Q2: Can kids take these supplements?  

A: Many kids can benefit from omega-3s, but dosing is different for little ones plus kids friendly versions that taste good are also available. It was given to kids traditionally as well. It's always best to check with your pediatrician first as to what works best for your kid. 

Q3: Why does my fish oil make me burp... fish?  

A: Fishy burps are experienced when the oil breaks down in your stomach. It's better to take it with food, try enteric-coated capsules, or keep your supplements in the freezer. The freezer slows down the breakdown and reduces the fishy aftertaste! 

References